Paul Mupa (368-392)

Back...

Participant observation on classroom practices and learner performance at a high school in Masvingo, Zimbabwe

Paul Mupa

Department of Educational Studies, Faculty of Education, Zimbabwe Open University, Masvingo, Zimbabwe

Abstract

This qualitative case study examines the classroom practices and instructional strategies employed at a high school in Masvingo, Zimbabwe, to understand the factors contributing to persistent learner underperformance. Framed by the School Effectiveness Framework and Vygotsky´s Social Constructivist Theory, the research employed an in-depth, obtrusive participant observation methodology over eight months to generate rich, contextual data within a purposively selected high school setting. A convenience sample of teachers and instructional documents provided the primary units of analysis. Findings reveal systemic barriers to effective teaching and learning. These include teacher-centred instructional delivery that limits student engagement, ineffective assessment and feedback practices characterised by inconsistent marking and demotivating comments, inadequate quantity and quality of written work, absence of differentiated instruction, and low-level questioning techniques that fail to develop critical thinking. Findings indicate that students repeatedly fail the same concepts across multiple assessment types, suggesting fundamental weaknesses in instructional design, formative assessment, and remedial practices. The study concludes that improved classroom performance requires a deliberate shift from content-coverage models to learning-mastery frameworks, supported by targeted professional development in diagnostic assessment, differentiated instruction, and constructive feedback practices. Recommendations include mandatory declaration of clear learning objectives, structured corrections-of-corrections processes, and classroom-based coaching on equitable questioning techniques and quality written work design. The study contributes new insights to the Zimbabwean educational scholarship by providing empirical evidence of the gap between policy intentions and classroom realities, illuminating the micro-level practices that perpetuate underperformance despite systemic reform efforts.

Keywords: classroom performance, diagnosis, individualised instruction, remediation, concept mastery, interaction, participant observation

How to cite this article: Mupa, P. (2026). Participant Observation on Classroom Practices and Learner Performance at a High School in Masvingo, Zimbabwe. African Perspectives of Research in Teaching and Learning, 10(2), 368-392.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.70875/v10i2article11  

Date published: 11 November 2026